Tampilkan postingan dengan label guest posts. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label guest posts. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 18 Juli 2013

Chasing Widows

Today's guest post is by Jim Lutzweiler, an archivist at the Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary.  In the post, he shares some stories about chasing widows in order to obtain collections, as well as some of the exciting holdings at the seminary.  I met Jim at the AP Grading, and have gotten to know him by running the camera for some oral history interviews in Chicago.  I can guarantee that if you do research at this archive, you'll hear some great stories if Jim is not off chasing widows.  Jim can be reached at jlutzweiler@sebts.edu.


My boys call me a widow chaser.  It’s true and it’s fun.  And sometimes I catch them and sometimes I don’t.


I assume my meaning is clear to anyone reading about the archive business.  But in case this moniker eludes a quick grasp, let me explain:  I try to preserve the papers of men (or women, but mostly men) who have made some contribution to American religious history.  Sometimes I get to their widows before they toss them, and sometimes I don’t.  More often it is the former, but sometimes the latter.

In re: the latter, I remember well and with no little archival pain a widow I was chasing because a friend suggested that I go easy on her husband before she became a widow.  My job hazard is giving off the ambience of a buzzard circling the still warm --but not very warm-- bodies of Baptist preachers and educators who have over their careers accumulated somewhat of a literary legacy. I followed my friend’s advice (after all, he had suggested the name to me), and the next thing you know the subject in question, a former seminary president, was dead.  And the next thing you know after that, his papers, like him, were toast.  Why? Because his admiring widow woke up every day and stared at his two four-drawer file cabinets full of his life’s work and began to miss him so much that she tossed them to kill the pain!  Since her son was a seminary president also, it never occurred to me that I should have just risked the buzzard paradigm.

Such losses are certainly the exception to the rule, though it is also true that some widows have been rumored to have burned their husband’s papers --and not because they missed their spouses.  I can think of one in northern Indiana, though her mate (also a seminary president) was not a Baptist.  And that is all the clue I am giving, as I am still working hard to forgive this lass, even posthumously.

A delightful alternative to this historical mindlessness is a widow I met in a very large (that’s a hint) southern state several years ago. For a year or so I had been chasing her husband, only to discover that he was dead and that he had been dead for some time.  It so happened that the brother of the deceased had once been the owner of the Minnesota Vikings.  And before that, he had owned the Denver Nuggets and the San Antonio Spurs --yes, the same Spurs who are playing this very week that I write.

Because of this connection, I managed to land an interview with the owner in question.  He had grown up in the First Baptist Church of Spur, Texas, after which town’s name many thought he had named his basketball team but which he had not.  When I called his office, I asked his secretary if he would permit me to interview him about Texas Baptist history.  This was not the sort of request that he received everyday; and at 4:30 that very same day, I was in his office with my camcorder for a 1.5 hour interview.  That was a wonderful occasion, and the interview is in the archives of Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary in Wake Forest, North Carolina, where I serve as the Archivist. The NFL owner in question is Red McCombs, and the rest is some delightful history which any researcher of faith or football is welcome to come to our seminary to see.

It turned out that Mary McCombs, the widow of Red’s brother, Gene, was still living in San Antonio.  Before long I made my way over to her house and did an oral history with her --and not only with her but with her son, Terrell.  And before much longer, Mary donated to our archives some of Gene’s books and also a collection of letters between her husband and his dear friend, Mack Cole, out in Fort Smith, Montana, not far from the Battle of the Little Big Horn.  Those letters are now part of our archives.  And now we know a lot more about Mary’s husband, Gene, who was the original object of my pursuit.

Time and space fail me to condense the substance of what we now know about Rev. Gene McCombs.  But one story will suffice to whet any normal researcher’s appetite.  The story in its entirety is on the DVD interview with Gene’s brother.  Red tells the story therein about when his brother was young and felt a call to the ministry.  He said everyone tried to talk him out of it, even his pastor.  That by itself is almost unprecedented in American religious history.  Just imagine, if you can, a Texas Baptist preacher trying to talk a teenager out of a call to preach.  I personally have never heard of such a thing, even though I have heard some preach to whom that advice might well have been given.

Gene’s sense of calling certainly seems justified, if one takes into consideration that he ended his long career as an associate preaching pastor of the nationally known television personality, Adrian Rogers, of the Bellevue Baptist Church (a church Elvis Presley used to sneak into late and leave early) in Memphis, Tennessee.  But things did not begin that auspiciously for Gene.

According to Red, a mutual friend of his and Gene’s came to him one day when Gene was in seminary.  The friend told Red that Gene was living close to poverty in order to chase his dream, the call to ministry he had heard.  He told Red that Gene didn’t have much food in the refrigerator and that for income he was mowing lawns with a borrowed mower.  Though he is a billionaire today, Red was not a billionaire then.  But he made his way up to Dallas and saw firsthand that what his friend had told him was true.  On camera, Red said that they both got down on their knees (most NFL owners only do that on Super Bowl Sunday), and there in prayer he told the Lord that Gene would live as he lived.  Thereafter, Gene did.

Red’s support of his brother was not without its problems, as Gene mostly pastored small churches, but he always owned a new car, a new house, and took trips to Europe.  This is one of my favorite “brother” stories of all time, as is one Mack Cole (to whom Red directed me for more Texas Baptist history) told in a sermon he sent me (a copy of which is in our archives).  It’s a story that makes a trip over here to Wake Forest and our archives more than simply worthwhile.  We have passion here as well as papers.  I have already written up this story elsewhere, and would be happy to email a copy of it to anyone interested enough to send me a request at jlutzweiler@sebts.edu.

In addition to some papers of Gene McCombs and three oral histories with his family members, the archives at Southeastern is full of many other Gospel goodies. A main focus of our collection strategy is the papers and oral histories of participants in what is known by its friends as the Conservative Resurgence in the Southern Baptist Convention and by its enemies as the "Takeover" --as in unbiblical theft-- of the Southern Baptist Convention.

One of the leading collections in this connection is that of Texas Judge Paul Pressler, co-architect with Paige Patterson of the Conservative Resurgence.  Pressler, characterized by a sloppy historian from Wake Forest University as a newcomer-sort-of-young-Turk to the SBC, is actually an eighty year-old descendant of one of the original founders of the SBC and a continuous host of Southern Baptist relatives who followed that founder from 1845 right down the trail to the Judge.

Not all of the collections in the archives are of Baptists.  One recent addition to our holdings is the papers of the Lutheran scholar, Dr. John Warwick Montgomery.  Montgomery is best remembered today for his debates with atheist Madeline Murray O'Hair and near atheist Bishop Pike.  Another addition is the papers of the evangelical thunderbolt Francis Schaeffer, a Presbyterian.

And not all of the collections in our archives are of Baptists sympathetic to the SBC of which Southeastern Baptist Seminary is an agency.  Some collections or individual pieces are from persons militantly opposed to the SBC.  The overall collection policy I have implemented is one taught to me by the late Methodist Governor, Senator, and Duke University President, Terry Sanford.  In reference to the Richard Nixon Library, over which Sanford's History Department fought him tooth and nail not to accept, Sanford told me in an oral history, "I would take the archives of the Devil, if the Devil would give them to me.”  So would I.
 




Rabu, 17 Juli 2013

The Strange Career of "the City on a Hill"

Today's guest post comes from Ben Wetzel, who is a PhD student in history at the University of Notre Dame.  He has published in the Journal of Church and State, as well as in The Activist Impulse: Essays on the Intersection of Evangelicalism and Anabaptism (Wipf & Stock, 2012).  His dissertation will focus on the intersection of American religion and politics, 1865-1920.    

Ben Wetzel

Perhaps the most famous article in all of American religious history is Perry Miller's 1953 piece in the William and Mary Quarterly entitled, "An Errand into the Wilderness."  Originally delivered at a meeting of the John Carter Brown Library in 1952, "An Errand into the Wilderness" reconceptualized the idea of a Puritan mission to the New World.  Expanding upon themes he had developed in The New England Mind (1939), Miller proposed that John Winthrop intended the Massachusetts Bay Colony to be a model for Europe (and perhaps the rest of the world) to imitate.  To buttress this view, Miller seized upon several lines of Winthrop's now famous Modell of Christian Charity: For wee must Consider that wee shall be as a Citty upon a Hill, the eies of all people are uppon us."  At the conclusion of his article, Miller even implied that there was a direct connection between Winthrop's vision and the founding of the United States: "Having failed to rivet their eyes upon their city on a hill," he wrote, "they were left alone with America."


To students of American religion, this connection between the "city on a hill" and the mission of the United States is hardly a new concept.  Anyone familiar with the rhetoric of Ronald Reagan, for example, knows that the president frequently connected the two ideas, adding the adjective "shining" to describe the model city.  Today Democrats and Republicans alike employ the image to describe the example they believe the United States should set for the rest of the world.

But to previous generations of Americans, the connection would not have been obvious.  In a wonderfully enlightening book, In Search for the City on a Hill: the Making and Unmaking of an American Myth (Continuum, 2012), historian Richard M. Gamble of Hillsdale College traces the evolution of the phrase's meaning in American history.  He argues that the phrase "city on a hill" (found in Matthew 5:14) originally described the mission of the church, but that over time the secular state has come to exert a near monopoly over the image.

Gamble begins the book with surprising observations about Winthrop's famous discourse, A Modell of Christian Charity.  Much is unknown about the circumstances surrounding the sermon's composition.  Indeed, since no one onboard the Arbella (the ship that transported the Puritans from England to Massachusetts) ever left any record of the message, and since Winthrop himself never mentioned giving the speech in his journal, Gamble concludes that it is possible that the governor never delivered the discourse at all.  In any case, Gamble points out, Winthrop could hardly have been envisioning the United States, whose tenets of toleration, individualism, and democracy the governor would have found appalling.

Proceeding in time, Gamble traces the fate of the "city on a hill" throughout American history.  Jonathan Edwards, for example, used the image in the 1730s to describe his Northampton congregation, but did so usually to chastise his church for failing to uphold true godliness.  When Edwards used the image, however, he was not alluding to Winthrop's vision, because A Modell of Christian Charity was not published until 1838.  Few observers in the 1830s noted its appearing, and none thought they saw the origins of the American mission in its contents.  Indeed, over the next century, writers who quoted from the document almost never drew attention to the "city on a hill" passage at all.

The transformation of the image began with Perry Miller's revisionist work in the second third of the twentieth century.  A professor of literature at Harvard, Miller rescued the Puritans from the ill repute to which previous generations of historians had consigned them.  Although he himself was an atheist, Miller admired the Puritans' intellectual world and did a great deal to rehabilitate them for the twentieth-century academy.  As we have seen, his "Errand into the Wilderness" article proposed a greater importance for the Modell of Christian Charity than previous scholars had supposed.

Still, it was not an academic but a politician who first used the phrase in a more public setting.  And his name was not Ronald Reagan.  Instead, John F. Kennedy (reading a speech prepared by his aide Ted Sorenson) declared to the Massachusetts state legislature in 1961 that he "had been guided by the standard John Winthrop set before his shipmates on the flagship Arbella three hundred and thirty-one years ago, as they, too, faced the task of building a new government on a perilous frontier."  And then: "'We must always consider' [Winthrop] said, 'that we shall be as a city upon a hill--the eyes of all people are upon us.'"  Clearly, as Gamble points out, the Irish-Catholic Kennedy's conception of the "city on a hill" was a far cry from what Winthrop would have envisioned in the seventeenth century, let alone what Jesus was describing in the gospel of Matthew.

It is unclear if Reagan learned of the phrase directly from Kennedy or picked it up elsewhere, but in any case the Great Communicator made the image his own in the last third of the twentieth century.  As with Kennedy, Reagan's use of the "city on a hill" was largely devoid of any specifically Christian content.  Instead, as the high priest of America's civil religion, Reagan deployed the image as a stand-in for a vague Americanism.  Although some critics of the president, such as New York governor Mario Cuomo, argued that there was a good bit wrong with the "shining city," for the most part the phrase had been adopted by both parties and emptied of any prophetic content by the end of the twentieth century.

In addition to Gamble's persuasive argument and admirable conclusion, which calls present-day Christians to think more discerningly about the differences between the City of God and the City of Man, there is much to like about this book.  First, it is written in an accessible style that is attractive to a general audience as well as to the historical profession.  Gamble's decision to publish with Continuum (a division of Bloomsbury) and his frequent references to "the reading public" demonstrate an important resolve to speak to a wider group than the academy.  Since the subject matter should be interesting to many kinds of people, and since Gamble is professionally qualified to write about American history, In Search of the City on a Hill seems to me to be an ideal example of what popular history can be.  Second, drawing on the writing of historian John Lukacs, Gamble calls us to think less about what ideas do to people, and more about what people do with ideas.  Since ideas never exist in a vacuum, scholars of all kinds might fruitfully consider tracing the changing shape of ideas over time.

In Search of the City on a Hill is a needed corrective to popular misconceptions about the Puritans, the "city on a hill," and United States.  Although some of this book's argument has been anticipated before (especially in Theodore Dwight Bozeman's To Live Ancient Lives: The Primitivist Dimension in Puritanism [UNC, 1988]), Gamble's work is refreshing and necessary in the twenty first century. 

Sabtu, 13 Juli 2013

Religion, Medicine, and Native Peoples in the Pacific Northwest

Today's guest post is from Suzanne Crawford O’Brien, Associate Professor of Religion and Culture at Pacific Lutheran University, where she teaches classes in Native American religious traditions, religion and healing, religious diversity in North America, and comparative theories of religion.  Her book, Coming Full Circle: Spirituality and Wellness among Native Communities in the Pacific Northwest will be released by University of Nebraska Press this fall. Suzanne also contributed the essay on Native American Religions for my anthology Columbia Guide to Religion in American History.

Suzanne Crawford O’Brien

In 1883, Reverend Myron Eells ordered a sixteen year old Skokomish Indian girl, “Ellen Gray” confined to her room.  (The Skokomish are part of a larger cultural and linguistic group known as the Coast Salish, which stretches from British Columbia, through Western Washington to the Tillamook on the Oregon Coast.)  Eells set guards at her door, and ordered them to keep out any Native healers, friends, or family members who might try to see her. The girl was sick, suffering from congestion, a chill, and what he referred to as “suppression of menses.”  Her real sickness, he was certain, was entirely psychological, brought on by a superstitious certainty that a dangerous spirit power (“tamanawas” in the local trade jargon that Eells used) had entered her, and needed to be removed.  Finally, one night Eels reports that she “threw off the clothes, took cold, and would not make any effort to cough and clear her throat and on the twenty-second she died, actually choking to death.” He concluded that “it was a tolerably clear case of death by imagination.” 

Eells’ story highlights the ways religion and medicine intersected in the colonial Northwest—and how that intersection impacted the lives of Native people.  Following a century of epidemic diseases (the first wave of smallpox likely hit the area in the 1780s, before the arrival of any Europeans), missionization, and the creation of reservations, Native communities like those of Ellen Gray were demographically and culturally devastated. Their traditional healers were floundering, unable to address new illnesses and social conflicts. Long term poverty and hunger were being experienced for perhaps the first time by a people who had lived for millennia in an environment rich in abundant resources.  Euroamerican settlers had outlawed Native religion and healing practices, actively suppressing and imprisoning ceremonial leaders, and enforcing the conversion of Native people through mandatory boarding schools and other forms of coercion.  The story of Ellen Gray exemplifies this moment of history, and the way it played out upon the body of one young girl. 


Her story is also striking because of what was soon to follow. The Indian Shaker Church (no connection to the East coast Shakers) was taking shape in 1883.  The Indian Shaker Church was a prophetic and charismatic healing movement that combined Catholic ritual, Protestant doctrine, and indigenous approaches to healing, spirituality, community, and ethics.  The movement quickly spread throughout the Northwest, sparking religious and social revitalization.  Had Indian Shaker healers been allowed to see Ms. Gray, her outcome may have been very different. 

And, her story is particularly poignant as a contrast to the contemporary context.  The 1975 Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act paved the way for tribes throughout the United States to acquire control over their own medical and social services.  Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, a growing number of tribal groups contracted with the federal government to provide their own care.  In Washington State tribes like the Skokomish, of which Ellen Gray was a member, now have their own wellness centers, providing holistic care that runs the gambit from biomedicine, mental health care, drug and alcohol counseling, vocational rehabilitation and training, education assistance, and complementary and alternative medicine such as massage and acupuncture. It is not at all unusual for such wellness centers to include ceremonial spaces where local religious leaders can hold ceremonies for patients, or to refer patients to local religious specialists who can provide such care.  Such ceremonies might be as simple as a smudging ceremony (brushing sage smoke over a patient, which requires the temporary disconnecting of smoke detectors), or a complex all-night healing ceremony in a Shaker church or longhouse. 

The way in which biomedicine is being integrated alongside traditional healing traditions provides a fascinating window into the ways in which religion and healthcare intersect, and how “tradition” can take surprising new forms.  From 2000 to 2006, for instance, I volunteered with Native communities in the south Puget Sound as they coordinated their annual Intertribal Intergenerational Women and Girls Gathering. The four day weekend—which took place at a 4-H camp on the shores of a lake surrounded by second growth forest—provided workshops on basketry, beading, drum making, herbalism, a sweat lodge and a traditional giveaway.  It also provided free mammograms, pap smears, diabetes screening, lessons on self-breast-exams, nutritional guidance, tai chi, massage, Reiki, and reflexology. For the women at the Gathering, such seemingly divergent activities flowed smoothly together. If they promoted a healthy person within community, if they strengthened women to uphold their families, communities, and cultural traditions, then, the women argued, they fit within Coast Salish traditions of health and wellness.

While Eels and other missionaries sought to stamp out Native religions and impose their own exclusive version of Christianity, Native communities have carved out a space for spirituality that is inclusive and strikingly ecumenical. A Coast Salish person might participate in traditional spirit dancing in the winter, be part of the Indian Shaker Church on occasions through the spring and summer, and attend a Pentecostal church at other times of year.  Consider for instance in 2005 when the Skokomish nation dedicated a new addition to their Wellness Center: the structure was blessed by the local Assembly of God pastor, elders from the Indian Shaker Church, and a traditional spiritual leader from the longhouse spirit dancing tradition.

Since the 1970s, Native communities of the Pacific Northwest have experienced a dramatic revival of religion, culture, and political agency. They have regained treaty fishing and gathering rights, have gained control over their education, healthcare, and social services, and are fighting (sometimes successfully) to protect sacred sites and resources.  Each summer, tribal communities in western Washington and British Columbia join together in Tribal Journeys, an intertribal canoe journey, wherein “canoe families” paddle hand carved canoes sometimes hundreds of miles, meeting up at traditional village sites along the way.  The Journey concludes with a week-long gathering of thousands of Native people, welcoming the canoes and celebrating traditional culture. Members of each nation make passionate speeches, offer their songs and dances, and celebrate their traditions.  This year, the final week’s celebrations take place August 1-6 in Tahola, WA on the Quinault reservation.

The focus of Tribal Journeys is healing, sobriety, and cultural renewal.  As Charlene Krise, a tribal council member of the Squaxin Island nation has put it, the Canoe Journey is a modern day soul retrieval ceremony.  Traditionally, illness could be attributed to the loss of one’s soul: perhaps it had been spirited away to the land of the dead. A healer was employed to make the spiritual journey, and retrieve that person’s soul. Often, that ceremony took place in a symbolic canoe, the healer “paddling” in spirit to the other side. Today, in contrast to the tragic experience of Ellen Gray, sixteen year old Skokomish girls can be found paddling their tribe’s canoe, making the arduous (and sometimes dangerous) journey.  It is a labor of prayer, song, reflection, and celebration.  And in the process, they are retrieving and renewing not only their own soul, but the soul of their nation.