Tampilkan postingan dengan label religion and politics. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label religion and politics. Tampilkan semua postingan

Senin, 22 Juli 2013

Secularists All!, or, Writing Religion and Diplomacy after Preston


Mark Edwards
Andrew Preston’s Sword of the Spirit, Shield of Faith (Anchor, 2012)  is a monumental achievement in the field of religion and politics—testified to by its winning of Canada’s Charles Taylor Prize for Literary Nonfiction.  A significant accomplishment for a country with (WARNING: 30 Rock reference, not author's opinion) only 700 words in their dictionary.   In many ways, Swordrepresents the capstone on if not completion of the “religious turn” in Diplomatic History.  For several years now, Preston has been leading a number of scholars trying to convince historians of foreign relations (SHAFR) that faith matters (see Cara Burnidge's important recent post on religion and SHAFR here).  Swordis so successful at tracking religious presence in U. S. foreign policy traditions that it is forcing me to ask a different question: Why is there so much secularism in the diplomatic discourse of the American Century?


I’m planning on taking up that question in my second (or maybe third, or maybe never) book on the worlds made and remade by Francis and Helen Hill Miller.  As the chairman of the World’s Student Christian Federation (WSCF) and one of the architects of the World Council of Churches (WCC), Miller was a centerpiece of my first book on the politics of ecumenical Protestantism.  He was especially significant in imagining, during the 1930s, the rise of a “World Christian Community” which could stand against the unholy trinity of secularism, corporate capitalism, and hyper-nationalism (totalitarianism).  I am now interested in Miller and his wife (a University of Chicago-trained political scientist and international relations theorist) as agents of secularization, notably in their roles as interpreters of post-WWI global American power.

This new project is less concerned with the Millers themselves than it is about their many “worlds.”  One meaning of “worlds” is the multitude of religious and secular institutions they inhabited.  Arguably the most important was the Council on Foreign Relations.  It should not be surprising that students of religion have ignored the Council, since it has historically had little patience for god-talk.  In fact, one of the apparent purposes for founding the Council was to move diplomacy away from reliance on religious typologies of “Christian” versus “heathen” nations.  Members rather looked to science, and empirical research, as a foundation for what Robert Schulzinger has termed the Council’s “realistic Wilsonianism.”  Of course, faith in scientific over providential knowledge was simply one dimension of the “anarchy” (Amy Kaplan) of the Council’s vision: Science itself was in the service of members’ gendered worldview—their search for “tough-minded” policies to supplant the failed “soft” Wilsonian settlement.  And yet the Council’s self-prophesying secularism was sustained, and even carried forward, by devout Protestant internationalists like Miller and several more mainline church leaders.  The irony of Christian Americans aiding and abetting the secularization of U.S. diplomacy peaked in the publication of Henry Luce’s American Century” article in 1941—a statement remarkable for its godlessness, given that it was penned by a missionary kid.  (Consider, by way of contrast, Henry Wallace’s rejoinder to Luce, “The Century of the Common Man” (1943), which was littered with Christian apocalyptic speech.)


One final admission: While Francis insisted to his dying day that democracy was impossible apart from a Christian moral foundation, there was a corresponding relationship for him and Helen between secularization and democratization.  Put more simply, the Millers were passionate advocates for participatory democracy.  Helen (a disciple of Jane Addams) wrote pamphlets on participatory democratic methods for the Agricultural Adjustment Administration.  In 1938, Francis was put in charge of the Council’s experiment in local foreign policy debate clubs.  Eventually, Miller would make participatory democratization a cornerstone of his campaigns of Governor and Senator in Cold War Virginia.

I’ll be in Princeton at the Mudd Library this August studying Miller’s clubs and many other dimensions of the CFR archives.  After eating too many gyros in the evenings, I’m hoping to read further into secularization theory—starting with John Modern’s “metaphysics of secularism.”  This new direction is admittedly indebted to arguments made some time ago by my graduate advisor Susan Curtis, although Christian Smith’s “Secular Revolution” is also currently written all over it.  As I begin to compile a “to read” list, I thought I’d ask RIAH readers: What secular-ism/ization theory(ist) can’t you live without?

Sabtu, 20 Juli 2013

The Radical Middle Path: Jesus According to Ingersoll, Herron, and Debs

Paul Putz

The twentieth of every month is about to get a whole lot less interesting for readers of this blog. That's because instead of getting a dose of historian extraordinaire Ed Blum, you'll get to read words typed by a first-year doctoral candidate whose last name doubles as an old-timey derogatory term. If you're a regular reader, then you'll finally know how Chicago Bulls fans felt when Pete Myers replaced Michael Jordan in 1994.

By way of introduction, I suppose I should mention my area of research (Gilded Age/Progressive Era religion in emerging American West urban settings), my school (Baylor), my favorite rap album (Mos Def's Black on Both Sides), my previous occupation (high school social studies teacher in Omaha, Nebraska), and my most annoying habit (using parenthesis way too much).

Now onto more interesting things, like David Burns' The Life and Death of the Radical Historical Jesus (Oxford, 2013).

At the heart of Burns' work is a seeming paradox, an argument for what he calls the "radical middle path." This path was trod by "secular-minded religionists" of the late-19th and early-20th century who sought to find some way to balance the demands of reason and religion, and ultimately found their answer by infusing a secular worldview with religious imagination, or, as Burns puts it, "finding divinity in Jesus' humanity." These freethinkers, socialists, and anarchists, Burns claims, have been overlooked by previous historians of religious history partly because the standard interpretation is that religious modernism was a movement controlled by the liberal professional theologians and academics embedded in elite universities and seminaries. Thus, radical modernists who were outside the stratosphere of the elites have been neglected. Burns believes that his book serves to correct the standard narrative. 

Of course, it takes three paths to make a middle path. For Burns, it seems that his radical middle only emerges when the right has been entirely cropped out of the picture. In other words, his is a middle path for those already oriented to the religious left, a path nestled somewhere in between the evangelical center-left and the scientific modernist left.  

Central to Burns' narrative stands the figure of Jesus, or at least the Jesus constructed by radical religionists like Robert Ingersoll, George Herron, Bouck White, and Eugene Debs. This radical historical Jesus was a blend of fact and fiction, a fossil excavated with the tools of biblical criticism and brought to life via the imagination of radical religionists who "secularized the sacred." As the title of the book suggests, Burns believes that the radical Jesus was a distinct American phenomenon. Although he notes that it was part of a larger tradition of challenging religious authority, he argues that the radical historical Jesus can be traced from its beginning in the 1860s to its ultimate end during World War I.

If you'll allow me to vastly oversimplify and stretch a metaphor to the point of breaking, here's how I would summarize Burns' narrative argument: French scholar Ernest Renan's Life of Jesus (published in English in 1864) was the "radical historical Jesus" seed, and Robert Ingersoll's role was to till the soil and spread the seed around within his vast network of freethinkers, anarchists, and socialists. The seed was watered by George Herron and Cyrenus Osborn Ward on militant socialist soil, sprouting from their work as "a combative carpenter in a socialist account." From there, the radical historical Jesus flowered under Bouck White (whose 1911 The Call of the Carpenter was the "definitive radical rereading of Christ"), before taking its ripened form under the care of Eugene Debs (the "most powerful disciple of the radical historical Jesus during the Progressive Era"), only to be choked to death by the weeds of the World War I-era nationalistic "Prince of Preparedness." By the 1920s the corporate-capitalist Christ and the white-supremacist Christ were too prevalent in the popular consciousness to allow for any renewed growth of the radical Jesus. Furthermore, the secular-revolutionary mindset of the radical religionists was not able to hold sway over subsequent leftist Christs, including the social justice Christ or the black liberation Christ. Thus the radical historical Jesus continues to lie dormant, another of the many casualties of the Great War. 

Burns' decision to begin with and focus on Renan's Life of Jesus perhaps obscures the influences of other conceptions of Jesus that were already prominent in America by the 1860s. For example, in Prophetic Encounters: Religion and the American Radical Tradition (profiled here by Janine Giordano Drake) Dan McKanan credits George Lippard with introducing and advancing the working-class, carpenter-Jesus in antebellum America, and even traces the influence of Lippard's Jesus down to Eugene Debs. It seems that Burns differentiates his radical Jesus from other types by suggesting that the radical Jesus 1) emerged from modern biblical criticism, 2) possessed no traces of divinity, 3) was depicted in imaginative detail to fill in biographical gaps, 4) opposed institutions and organized Christianity, and 5) was interested in social revolution, especially anarchism or socialism.

But did the individuals studied by Burns self-consciously believe that those traits constituted a unique radical Jesus? To what extent is this radical historical Jesus first constructed by Burns and then read back into the radical protagonists’ thoughts and words? Was there really a distinct and traceable radical Jesus that dominated the mindset of Ingersoll, Herron, and Debs, and was mostly independent of the influence of, say, the working-class, carpenter-Christ of George Lippard? I ask these questions without feeling like I have the historical acumen to answer them for myself quite yet. But I think they are worth considering.

Burns has an obvious admiration for the subjects of his study. Their stories, he writes, "provide evidence that flawed and fallible individuals can learn, grow, and become more thoughtful and empathetic." And their discovery of the radical historical Jesus led them to "become more sympathetic and understanding beings capable of reaching out to and embracing different groups and people." The implication seems to be that liberal modernists and religious traditionalists were not quite as capable of such things.

Burns also brings his historical subjects into a modern context, lamenting the disappearance of the radical historical Jesus from current public discourse. He dismisses the Jesus of the Jim Wallis-led contemporary evangelical left on the grounds that he is too moderate and too tolerant of religious traditionalists. And rationalists like Sam Harris come under fire for possessing an ideology that is closer to Lyman Abbot's imperialism than Robert Ingersoll's humanism. Instead of our current system of hard and fast lines between religion and reason, the sacred and the secular, Burns believes that the American radical religionists of 1870-1920 can point us toward a middle ground that recognizes both the "sordid and sublime" in religion, and allows for the power of imagination to bring religious life to a secular mindset.

One is left wondering at the end of the book if Burns sees his project as a continuation of the project of his radical protagonists. Herron, White, and Debs imaginatively reconstructed the historical Jesus to provide inspiration for their own social projects. In some ways, this books reads as if Burns has imaginatively reconstructed the radical religionists to infuse life and inspiration into his vision of a radical middle path in our own day. But then, to what extent do all historians, particularly those of religion, imaginatively reconstruct history to advance their own ideals? Alas, that is a question that I assume I will be dealing with for the rest of my career, however long or short.

As for Burns' book, I haven't even mentioned the attention that he provides to the labor movement and the Socialist Party, both of which make this book a work of labor and political history as much as it is a work of religious history. In fact, the blurbs on the back come from three people outside the field of American religious history: Charles Postel, Robert D. Johnston, and the Jesus Seminar's own John Dominic Crossan. It is a fascinating read throughout, in no small part because Burns is able to deftly navigate his way through multiple historical fields. I'd recommend it to religious historians interested in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, the labor movement, the American radical tradition (if there is such a thing), or the increasingly blurry line (if there is such a thing) between secularism and religion.

Rabu, 17 Juli 2013

The Strange Career of "the City on a Hill"

Today's guest post comes from Ben Wetzel, who is a PhD student in history at the University of Notre Dame.  He has published in the Journal of Church and State, as well as in The Activist Impulse: Essays on the Intersection of Evangelicalism and Anabaptism (Wipf & Stock, 2012).  His dissertation will focus on the intersection of American religion and politics, 1865-1920.    

Ben Wetzel

Perhaps the most famous article in all of American religious history is Perry Miller's 1953 piece in the William and Mary Quarterly entitled, "An Errand into the Wilderness."  Originally delivered at a meeting of the John Carter Brown Library in 1952, "An Errand into the Wilderness" reconceptualized the idea of a Puritan mission to the New World.  Expanding upon themes he had developed in The New England Mind (1939), Miller proposed that John Winthrop intended the Massachusetts Bay Colony to be a model for Europe (and perhaps the rest of the world) to imitate.  To buttress this view, Miller seized upon several lines of Winthrop's now famous Modell of Christian Charity: For wee must Consider that wee shall be as a Citty upon a Hill, the eies of all people are uppon us."  At the conclusion of his article, Miller even implied that there was a direct connection between Winthrop's vision and the founding of the United States: "Having failed to rivet their eyes upon their city on a hill," he wrote, "they were left alone with America."


To students of American religion, this connection between the "city on a hill" and the mission of the United States is hardly a new concept.  Anyone familiar with the rhetoric of Ronald Reagan, for example, knows that the president frequently connected the two ideas, adding the adjective "shining" to describe the model city.  Today Democrats and Republicans alike employ the image to describe the example they believe the United States should set for the rest of the world.

But to previous generations of Americans, the connection would not have been obvious.  In a wonderfully enlightening book, In Search for the City on a Hill: the Making and Unmaking of an American Myth (Continuum, 2012), historian Richard M. Gamble of Hillsdale College traces the evolution of the phrase's meaning in American history.  He argues that the phrase "city on a hill" (found in Matthew 5:14) originally described the mission of the church, but that over time the secular state has come to exert a near monopoly over the image.

Gamble begins the book with surprising observations about Winthrop's famous discourse, A Modell of Christian Charity.  Much is unknown about the circumstances surrounding the sermon's composition.  Indeed, since no one onboard the Arbella (the ship that transported the Puritans from England to Massachusetts) ever left any record of the message, and since Winthrop himself never mentioned giving the speech in his journal, Gamble concludes that it is possible that the governor never delivered the discourse at all.  In any case, Gamble points out, Winthrop could hardly have been envisioning the United States, whose tenets of toleration, individualism, and democracy the governor would have found appalling.

Proceeding in time, Gamble traces the fate of the "city on a hill" throughout American history.  Jonathan Edwards, for example, used the image in the 1730s to describe his Northampton congregation, but did so usually to chastise his church for failing to uphold true godliness.  When Edwards used the image, however, he was not alluding to Winthrop's vision, because A Modell of Christian Charity was not published until 1838.  Few observers in the 1830s noted its appearing, and none thought they saw the origins of the American mission in its contents.  Indeed, over the next century, writers who quoted from the document almost never drew attention to the "city on a hill" passage at all.

The transformation of the image began with Perry Miller's revisionist work in the second third of the twentieth century.  A professor of literature at Harvard, Miller rescued the Puritans from the ill repute to which previous generations of historians had consigned them.  Although he himself was an atheist, Miller admired the Puritans' intellectual world and did a great deal to rehabilitate them for the twentieth-century academy.  As we have seen, his "Errand into the Wilderness" article proposed a greater importance for the Modell of Christian Charity than previous scholars had supposed.

Still, it was not an academic but a politician who first used the phrase in a more public setting.  And his name was not Ronald Reagan.  Instead, John F. Kennedy (reading a speech prepared by his aide Ted Sorenson) declared to the Massachusetts state legislature in 1961 that he "had been guided by the standard John Winthrop set before his shipmates on the flagship Arbella three hundred and thirty-one years ago, as they, too, faced the task of building a new government on a perilous frontier."  And then: "'We must always consider' [Winthrop] said, 'that we shall be as a city upon a hill--the eyes of all people are upon us.'"  Clearly, as Gamble points out, the Irish-Catholic Kennedy's conception of the "city on a hill" was a far cry from what Winthrop would have envisioned in the seventeenth century, let alone what Jesus was describing in the gospel of Matthew.

It is unclear if Reagan learned of the phrase directly from Kennedy or picked it up elsewhere, but in any case the Great Communicator made the image his own in the last third of the twentieth century.  As with Kennedy, Reagan's use of the "city on a hill" was largely devoid of any specifically Christian content.  Instead, as the high priest of America's civil religion, Reagan deployed the image as a stand-in for a vague Americanism.  Although some critics of the president, such as New York governor Mario Cuomo, argued that there was a good bit wrong with the "shining city," for the most part the phrase had been adopted by both parties and emptied of any prophetic content by the end of the twentieth century.

In addition to Gamble's persuasive argument and admirable conclusion, which calls present-day Christians to think more discerningly about the differences between the City of God and the City of Man, there is much to like about this book.  First, it is written in an accessible style that is attractive to a general audience as well as to the historical profession.  Gamble's decision to publish with Continuum (a division of Bloomsbury) and his frequent references to "the reading public" demonstrate an important resolve to speak to a wider group than the academy.  Since the subject matter should be interesting to many kinds of people, and since Gamble is professionally qualified to write about American history, In Search of the City on a Hill seems to me to be an ideal example of what popular history can be.  Second, drawing on the writing of historian John Lukacs, Gamble calls us to think less about what ideas do to people, and more about what people do with ideas.  Since ideas never exist in a vacuum, scholars of all kinds might fruitfully consider tracing the changing shape of ideas over time.

In Search of the City on a Hill is a needed corrective to popular misconceptions about the Puritans, the "city on a hill," and United States.  Although some of this book's argument has been anticipated before (especially in Theodore Dwight Bozeman's To Live Ancient Lives: The Primitivist Dimension in Puritanism [UNC, 1988]), Gamble's work is refreshing and necessary in the twenty first century.